Stopping Yourself


I read on a bulletin board a traders comment that on his first outing trading the E-Mini S&P 500 he lost on each of his trades. He noted though, that had he had a wider stop each of his trades would have been profitable and that therefore he would be trading with a wider stop in future.

A wider stop on these particular trades may have worked, but this does not mean that a wider stop per se is the answer. In fact, everyday there is the possibility of any given trade going into profit if given enough room, but that does not a wise strategy make. This trader was a seller in a market that subsequently went down; hence he could see that had he given his position a bit more room he would have made a handsome profit. Unless this trader has the ability to always accurately predict the direction of the market he is going to experience days where he is wrong and the market goes against him, in which case his potential for loss with wider stops is greater.

When deciding an appropriate amount to risk on any trade (i.e. size of stop) a trader has to consider more than the potential profit on a particular trade on a particular day. What this trader was saying to himself was 'If I had a 3 point stop instead of a 1 point stop, I could have made 15 points; therefore I will always use a 3 point stop!' Partly what he was saying to himself was 'I was right!' But he wasn't right; in the time frame of his trades and within the risk limit of those trades he was wrong, his timing was off and that is what he needs to work on.

He is also making two assumptions:

1) That having a bigger stop and therefore bigger open losses will not affect his trading composure and performance (how do you feel if you are risking $10?? $100?? $1000?? $10,000?)

2) That he would have held on to his profitable trade until he gets an exit signal (it is easy to assume after the event that we would have got out at the very best moment)

The truth is we are all much weaker than we would like to assume. The biggest challenge to profitable trading is sticking to our own self-imposed loss limits, be they on a per-day or a per-trade basis. What this trader did on this day was stick to his limits, which is highly commendable; he was just having difficulty accepting his results. No one likes losing money and no one like being wrong, but to be successful in trading we have to be accepting of both.

Malcolm Robinson
LIFFE Pit Trader & Electronic Trader
www.instinctivetrader.com/">InstinctiveTrader.com


MORE RESOURCES:

Maktoob Business (press release)

US stops short of branding China a currency manipulator
AFP - 3 hours ago
WASHINGTON (AFP) — The United States Thursday accused China of keeping its yuan currency "substantially undervalued," but stopped short of branding Beijing ...
US Declines to Say China Manipulates Its Currency New York Times
US declines to cite China as a currency manipulator The Associated Press
No major trade partner manipulates currency, says US Treasury Xinhua
Forbes - Reuters
all 201 news articles


CNBC

Dollar Falls Against Euro Before US Housing, Confidence Data
Bloomberg - 2 hours ago
The US currency pared a weekly advance against the euro as the yield advantage of German two-year debt over similar- maturity US Treasuries widened to the ...
Euro falls against dollar, yen The Age
The dollar's short-lived comeback CNNMoney.com
Dollar May Extend Drop Against Yen Before Confidence Report Bloomberg
Bloomberg - Bloomberg
all 394 news articles


Gulf Times

Indian Rupee Gains on Speculation Exporters Bought the Currency
Bloomberg - May 14, 2008
By Anil Varma May 15 (Bloomberg) -- India's rupee rose, reversing an earlier decline, on speculation exporters purchased the currency after it slumped to a ...
See Re at 44/$ levels in next 3-6 mnths: Deutsche Bk Moneycontrol.com
Re at 13-month low, set to slip below 43-mark Economic Times
India's Rupee Falls for Fourth Day to 13-Month Low on Crude Oil Bloomberg
Bloomberg - Bloomberg
all 100 news articles


CPI Financial

Barclays Bank Mexico's global local currency outlook cut to ...
Forbes, NY - 1 hour ago
MUMBAI (Thomson Financial) - Moody's Investors Service said it cut its outlook on Barclays Bank Mexico, SA's 'A1' global local currency deposit rating to ...
TEXT-Moody's release on Gas Authority (India) Limited (GAIL) Reuters India
First United Bank's domestic bonds assigned 'B3' currency debt ... Forbes
Paraguay's 'B3' currency ratings constrained by various factors ... Forbes
Forbes - Forbes
all 247 news articles


Yuan Gains Versus Currency Basket Signal Policy Shift (Update1)
Bloomberg - May 14, 2008
A chart of Westpac's weighted yuan index, which aims to mimic moves in China's currency basket, shows daily fluctuations were in a limited range since about ...
Mainland set to develop currency derivatives China Post
China yuan central parity rate set at 6.9895 to dollar vs 7.0000 Forbes
China Central Bank Targets `Illegal' Cash Inflows (Update1) Bloomberg
Forbes
all 20 news articles


Won up: Rupee gains currency in South Korea
Economic Times, India - 9 hours ago
NEW DELHI: After growing from strength to strength during 2007, the rupee may be losing ground against the dollar now, but the Indian currency has won a ...


Army recovers heroin, fake currency near Indo-Pak border
Hindustan Times, India - 10 minutes ago
PTI Troops have recovered a "consignment" of 60 kilograms of heroin and fake Indian currency with face value of Rs 16 lakhs near the Indo-Pak border, ...


Canadian Dollar Close to an Eight-Week High as Oil, Gold Surge
Bloomberg - 15 hours ago
``There is a small market shift in favor of the Canadian dollar,'' said Camilla Sutton, a currency strategist at Scotia Capital Inc. in Toronto, ...
Canadian dollar falls with oil prices, bonds mixed Reuters
Dollar Little Changed Before Reports on Production, Employment Bloomberg
Canadian Bonds Gain as Industrial Output Declines During March Bloomberg
Bloomberg - Bloomberg
all 53 news articles


Voice of America

Pakistan Foreign Currency Rating Lowered to B by S&P (Update2)
Bloomberg - 18 hours ago
By Khalid Qayum and Farhan Sharif May 15 (Bloomberg) -- Pakistan's foreign currency rating was cut one level to B by Standard & Poor's, citing government ...
S&P cuts Pakistan's debt rating; local shares fall MarketWatch
Bickering in Pakistan Times Online
Split in Pakistani coalition dashes hopes of many Reuters
all 1,703 news articles


Australian Dollar to Rise on China Investment, RBC Capital Says
Bloomberg - 2 hours ago
RBC recommends buying the Australian dollar against New Zealand's currency because China, the world's fastest-growing major economy, has more demand for raw ...
Australian, NZ Dollars Poised for Weekly Gain on Yield Demand Bloomberg
Australian Dollar Rises on Demand for Higher-Yielding Assets Bloomberg
NZ Dollar Falls on Retail Sales; Australian Dollar Advances Bloomberg
Bloomberg - Bloomberg
all 34 news articles

currency - Google News

site map
Nocommentweb.com © 2000 - Partners

psychology help | snus | ekspress lån | express loan | Santander Spain | cheap insurance | snus|